JournalArta
Sunday, November 22, 2026 · JakartaS&P 6,910.39 ▼3.70%USD/IDR 18,260 ▲0.14%
JournalArta
Global Edition
beyond headlines
Advertisement

Supreme Court Leaves Michigan School’s ‘Let’s Go Brandon’ Ruling in Place

The Supreme Court declined to hear an appeal by two Michigan middle school students disciplined for wearing “Let’s Go Brandon” sweatshirts. The decision leaves in place a lower court ruling favoring the school district and avoids a new ruling on how schools may restrict coded or potentially offensive speech. The case raised questions about student free-speech rights and the authority of schools to prevent classroom disruption.

By matthew jonathan
WIB3 min read
Supreme Court Leaves Michigan School’s ‘Let’s Go Brandon’ Ruling in Place
Supreme Court Leaves Michigan School’s ‘Let’s Go Brandon’ Ruling in Place

A school sweatshirt dispute put student speech rights before the Supreme Court. On Monday, the justices declined to hear an appeal from two Michigan middle school students who were ordered to remove sweatshirts bearing “Let’s Go Brandon,” leaving a lower court decision in favor of their school district intact.

The decision means the court will not clarify how far schools may go in restricting potentially offensive messages in classrooms. The dispute arose at Tri County Middle School, where a teacher and an assistant principal separately asked the brothers to take off the sweatshirts.

The students, identified by their initials in court papers, were in eighth and sixth grade at the time. Their family sued in 2023, alleging violations of the First and Fourteenth Amendments.

Advertisement

The phrase “Let’s Go Brandon” became right-wing code for “F**k Joe Biden.” It originated at a NASCAR race in 2021, when a crowd chanted the vulgar phrase and a reporter interviewing driver Brandon Brown suggested the spectators were cheering for him instead.

The Supreme Court’s refusal to take the case leaves the divided 6th US Circuit Court of Appeals ruling in place. The ruling favored the school district, which argued that a message can carry an offensive meaning even when its wording appears sanitized.

Supreme Court avoids a ruling on coded speech

The case could have further defined student free-speech rights, nearly six decades after the Supreme Court ruled that students do not lose First Amendment protections when they enter school. In Tinker v. Des Moines, the court allowed students to wear black armbands in protest of the Vietnam War.

Advertisement

That protection has limits. Schools may restrict speech that disrupts the classroom, and a 1986 Supreme Court precedent permits schools to prohibit vulgar or offensive language, depending on the context. The sweatshirt dispute raised the question of whether a coded phrase can fall within that exception.

The school district, represented by veteran Supreme Court lawyer Lisa Blatt, used examples in its brief to argue that meaning can be conveyed through innuendo and double meanings. One example was a T-shirt depicting President Donald Trump clutching cats with the words “And that’s how you GRAB EM!” The brief linked the image to the “Access Hollywood tape,” which captured Trump in 2005 speaking about groping and kissing women.

Advertisement

The district also cited the number 69 as an example of language whose meaning can change with context. “Although on its face it is just a number innocently falling between 68 and 70, many understand it to refer to a sexual position,” it told the Supreme Court. The brief added: “Respondents apologize for the use of offensive language and images in this brief.”

For schools, the unresolved question has practical consequences: administrators must judge not only the words printed on clothing but also what those words communicate in a particular setting. The court’s decision leaves the lower court’s ruling as the outcome in this dispute, without setting a new nationwide standard for coded student expression.

Advertisement

The Supreme Court has addressed related questions about student speech outside school. Five years ago, it ruled in favor of a former high school cheerleader who argued that her public school could not punish her for a profanity-laced Snapchat caption posted off campus.

That Pennsylvania case drew close attention because it involved how schools should balance students’ speech rights against concerns about off-campus and online messages that could disrupt a school’s mission, amount to bullying or constitute threats. Justice Stephen Breyer, who has since retired, wrote that dismissing a student’s words as unworthy of strong First Amendment protection could endanger broader protections. “But sometimes it is necessary to protect the superfluous in order to preserve the necessary,” he wrote.

Advertisement

The court also rejected an appeal from Dylann Roof, who was convicted of racially motivated hate crimes resulting in death for killing nine people at Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church in Charleston, South Carolina. Roof was sentenced to death.

Advertisement
What Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizTake the quizWhat Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizStart →
Advertisement
Most Read
  1. 1Magnitude 4.2 Earthquake Wakes Los Angeles Before DawnMagnitude 4.2 Earthquake Wakes Los Angeles Before Dawn
  2. 2Micron Says Memory Has Changed as Shares Fall 13.89%Micron Says Memory Has Changed as Shares Fall 13.89%
  3. 3Dow Jones Futures Await Reopening After Tech Stocks SlideDow Jones Futures Await Reopening After Tech Stocks Slide
  4. 4US Shoppers Reject Cheap Fabrics as Clothing Prices RiseUS Shoppers Reject Cheap Fabrics as Clothing Prices Rise
  5. 5ORCL Stock Week Ahead: Levels and Scenarios for November 23–27ORCL Stock Week Ahead: Levels and Scenarios for November 23–27
Advertisement
Don't Miss

Latest News

All stories →
  1. Michigan to Face UCLA Without Top Two Wide ReceiversSport · FootballMichigan to Face UCLA Without Top Two Wide ReceiversNov 22
  2. Australian Doctors Urge Health Review of Salmon AntibioticWorld · AustraliaAustralian Doctors Urge Health Review of Salmon AntibioticNov 22
  3. Notre Dame Safety Luke Talich Ruled Out Against SMU With Leg InjurySport · More SportsNotre Dame Safety Luke Talich Ruled Out Against SMU With Leg InjuryNov 22
  4. Pelicans vs. Spurs: Seven Players Listed on Injury ReportSport · BasketballPelicans vs. Spurs: Seven Players Listed on Injury ReportNov 22
  5. Advertisement
  6. Ferrari 296 Challenge Stradale Drops Hybrid PowerTechnology · GadgetsFerrari 296 Challenge Stradale Drops Hybrid PowerNov 22
  7. Wake Forest Enters Projected Playoff Field, Ohio State EliminatedSport · FootballWake Forest Enters Projected Playoff Field, Ohio State EliminatedNov 22
  8. Hirving Lozano Returns to San Diego as Galaxy Loan EndsSport · FootballHirving Lozano Returns to San Diego as Galaxy Loan EndsNov 22
  9. The real reason Senate leaders keep becoming incredibly unpopularWorld · United StatesThe real reason Senate leaders keep becoming incredibly unpopularNov 22