JournalArta
Monday, November 16, 2026 · JakartaS&P 7,423.97 ▼1.82%USD/IDR 18,263 ▲0.19%
JournalArta
Global Edition
beyond headlines
Advertisement

Being Sceptical of Medical Studies Can Help Protect Health

Medical studies often find links between diet, weight and illness, but a statistical association does not prove that one causes the other. A commentary argues that readers should consider the size and consistency of a risk before changing how they think about their health.

By Alistair Sterling
November 16, 20262 min read
Being Sceptical of Medical Studies Can Help Protect Health
Being Sceptical of Medical Studies Can Help Protect Health

Medical studies can shape public views of diet and disease, but being sceptical of medical studies may help readers distinguish a statistical link from a cause. A commentary by Theodore Dalrymple argues that people should look beyond alarming relative-risk claims when judging health findings.

Small risks can distract from larger ones.

Dalrymple points to changing ideas about obesity as an example of how medical understanding can shift. He writes that weight alone is not the only consideration: where excess weight is carried also matters.

He cites a finding that two-thirds of 46-year-olds classified as obese are in good health. The observation does not establish how their health will change over time.

Advertisement

Research can also lead people to treat an association as proof of cause, Dalrymple writes. A statistical link between a factor in someone’s diet or environment and an illness does not, by itself, show that the factor caused the illness.

To illustrate how such claims can be misunderstood, he offers a deliberately fictional example: a study says people eating more than three bananas a week are 58 per cent more likely to develop flat feet. He labels the scenario satire, not a factual study.

Dalrymple also describes a past episode involving selenium. After people who had suffered heart attacks were found to have low selenium levels, Brazil nuts, which contain high levels of the mineral, temporarily disappeared from supermarket shelves.

Advertisement

He cautions that eating too many Brazil nuts can cause selenium poisoning. The example shows how a reported association can prompt a response before it establishes that changing a diet will prevent illness.

Readers should consider absolute risk as well as relative risk, Dalrymple writes. A large relative increase may still amount to little if the disease is very rare, while attention to tiny risks can obscure substantial ones.

He recommends weighing several tests of whether an association is likely to be causal: how strong it is, whether there is a plausible biological explanation, whether other studies have found it, and whether greater exposure is linked to greater effect.

Advertisement

Experimental evidence alongside epidemiological research can also help assess a proposed cause, he writes. Dalrymple says a critical approach can keep people from worrying over weak associations while overlooking real dangers.

He adds that health risks do not necessarily follow a simple rule about weight: in his account, very thin people have higher mortality than slightly overweight people, who may have lower mortality than those at the “correct” weight.

Advertisement
Take the quizWhat Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizStart →
Advertisement
Most Read
  1. 1Micron Stock Falls 28% as $35.16 Billion Buyback Nears
  2. 2I’m A Celebrity 2026 Line-Up: Rooney Leads 11 Stars Into Jungle
  3. 3Taylor Swift and the Falcons Game Today: Chiefs in Atlanta
  4. 4Actor Says David Walliams Sexually Humiliated Him on Stage
  5. 5AI Inference Pricing: AWS, Azure and Google Cloud Costs
Advertisement
Don't Miss

Latest News

All stories →
  1. Markets · StocksCAR Share Price Update: Rises 1.11%, Up 1.6% in Five SessionsNov 16
  2. BusinessUniCredit Wins EU Approval for €45 Billion Commerzbank BidNov 16
  3. World · United StatesKen Urker’s Death Ruled Accidental Drug Toxicity, Coroner SaysNov 16
  4. Business · CompaniesBlack Rifle Coffee to Close at Least 12 Stores by Early 2027Nov 16
  5. Advertisement
  6. Markets · StocksWesfarmers Share Price Falls 0.82% (November 16, 2026): Up 1.5% in a MonthNov 16
  7. WorldBahrain Sentences 64 Shiite Clerics to Life in PrisonNov 16
  8. World · AustraliaQueensland hail reaches 10cm as storms bring flood riskNov 16
  9. Markets · StocksScentre Share Price Rises 0.85% on Monday, Up 2.9% in Five SessionsNov 16