JournalArta
Wednesday, November 18, 2026 · JakartaS&P 7,303.98 ▼0.50%USD/IDR 18,249 ▼0.07%
JournalArta
Global Edition
beyond headlines
Advertisement

At-Home Microbiome Tests Give Widely Different Results

At-home gut microbiome tests can produce sharply different results from the same person's stool, studies have found. Specialists say the science is not yet mature enough to support testing for most consumers, while companies point to differences in laboratory methods and defend their products.

By Elena Vance
November 18, 20262 min read
At-Home Microbiome Tests Give Widely Different Results
At-Home Microbiome Tests Give Widely Different Results

Scientists have found wide differences in results from at-home gut microbiome tests in studies in the United States and Europe. The findings raise questions for consumers who use the tests to guide health decisions.

The tests can cost around US$100–300. Specialists say their clinical usefulness is limited for most consumers and warn that following nonclinical advice could lead to restrictive diets or delayed medical assessment.

Companies stand by their products. They say laboratories use different methods to analyze the microorganisms living in the gut.

Tests disagreed on the same samples

Scientists at the US National Institute of Standards and Technology sent mixed stool samples from one person to seven companies. The institute researches and applies measurement standards.

Advertisement

Companies identified between 34 and 906 groups of related microbes, known as genera. Only 3 appeared in every report.

“They couldn’t even agree on what’s healthy and unhealthy,” said study co-author Scott Jackson, a molecular geneticist and former director of the institute's microbiology program.

A European and Canadian team sent mixed samples from one person's stool to six companies. Three rated microbial diversity excellent or good, two called it average, and one rated it unfavorable.

The researchers did not name the companies in either study. In the US study, scientists wanted to focus on comparisons between tests rather than the perceived accuracy of individual providers.

Advertisement

Methods and health advice vary

Differences can begin with sample collection and preservation, said Jack Gilbert, director of the Microbiome and Metagenomics Center at the University of California, San Diego.

Laboratory extraction methods can also favor different microbes, said institute microbiologist Stephanie Servetas. Gentler methods favor organisms that are easier to break open, while harsher methods capture more species with tougher exteriors.

Viome uses RNA sequencing to examine microbial gene activity, rather than only the presence of genes, said Momo Vuyisich, chief science officer at its lab. He argues that activity is more relevant to health.

Advertisement

Vuyisich said using the same provider should produce results comparable over time, despite biases in every method. Viome recommends retesting every four to six months to check for changes and update its eating plan.

Some companies also sell supplements. Viome offered customized supplements and probiotics costing more than $150 a month alongside dietary recommendations.

Gastroenterologist and immunologist Fergus Shanahan of University College Cork said consumer profiles are usually not specific enough to help people struggling with gut health. For a suspected infection, testing for a known pathogen is more straightforward, he said.

Kelly Moffat, chief operations officer at Cmbio, which performs laboratory work for NirvanaBiome, acknowledged the difficulty of applying results. “I think the jury’s out on exactly what it is that we can actionably do today based on this data,” she said.

Advertisement
Take the quizWhat Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizStart →
Advertisement
Most Read
  1. 1U.S. Emergency Alert Test Nov. 17 Is Not a Power Outage
  2. 2Gold Silver Price November: Futures Rise Near Yearly Lows
  3. 3Michael Clarke Says Sandpapergate Scars Drew Steve Smith to New York
  4. 4GTA 6 New Zealand Time Trick Is Not Guaranteed to Work
  5. 5Sunrise on the Reaping Reviews Split Over Dark Hunger Games Prequel
Advertisement
Don't Miss

Latest News

All stories →
  1. Sport · More SportsUtah Mammoth Unveil Winter Classic Jersey for Outdoor DebutNov 18
  2. Sport · More SportsMariners’ Randy Arozarena Rejects Qualifying Offer, Enters Free AgencyNov 18
  3. Markets · StocksAGL Energy Share Price Rises 0.11% on Wednesday, Near a 3-Month HighNov 18
  4. Technology · AIUK MHRA Launches AdvanceGxP to Speed Up AI and Hospital-Made MedicinesNov 18
  5. Advertisement
  6. Technology · Apps & SoftwareWhat CNI Status Means for UK Data Centre OperatorsNov 18
  7. World · Middle EastIsraeli Tanks Advance Into Central Gaza Beyond Truce LineNov 18
  8. Technology · GamingSony Issues PS5 Update Required to Play GTA 6Nov 18
  9. Business · EnergyUK Diesel Prices Hit Record as Inflation Reaches 3.6%Nov 18