JournalArta
Thursday, November 19, 2026 · JakartaS&P 7,323.63 ▼0.23%USD/IDR 18,261 ▲0.18%
JournalArta
Global Edition
beyond headlines
Advertisement

Two Anatomists Explain Why ‘New Organ’ Claims Keep Sparking Disputes

Another week, another headline about a "new organ." Two anatomists want to explain why the label rarely settles anything.

By Alistair Sterling
November 19, 20262 min read
Two Anatomists Explain Why 'New Organ' Claims Keep Sparking Disputes
Two Anatomists Explain Why 'New Organ' Claims Keep Sparking Disputes

Another week, another headline about a "new organ." Two anatomists want to explain why the label rarely settles anything.

Their newly published explainer tackles a question that keeps returning: after more than 2,500 years of dissection and imaging of the human body down to the nanometre, can there really be organs left to find?

Yes, they write. But the discoveries tend to land in controversy.

A pattern of pushback

One team announces an organ. Other researchers respond that it has been known for centuries. Some structures are claimed for all humans, while others argue they are not universal.

Then there is a third category: organs that clearly exist, where the disagreement is about what they actually do.

Advertisement

The anatomists say three such disputes sit in the head alone.

Waste disposal in the brain

Brain nerve cells produce waste that must be cleared for the brain to stay healthy. It is carried away in cerebrospinal fluid, the specialised liquid surrounding the central nervous system.

Scientists agree on that much. They do not agree on how the clearance works or which organs are involved.

For more than a century, anatomists believed small grape-like structures called arachnoid granulations carried out this job. Rival accounts of the machinery have since put that long-held picture under question.

What it means for readers

The disputes are more than academic housekeeping. Imaging has made it possible to describe structures in fine detail, but describing something is not the same as proving it qualifies as an organ.

Advertisement

When researchers cannot agree on whether a structure is universal, or on its function, the practical questions follow. What does it do? Does the answer vary between patients?

The two anatomists do not settle those disputes. Their explainer sets out why a discovery announcement and a classification argument are different things, and why the second often outlasts the first.

Advertisement
Take the quizWhat Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizStart →
Advertisement
Most Read
  1. 1Gold Silver Price November: Futures Rise Near Yearly Lows
  2. 2Michael Clarke Says Sandpapergate Scars Drew Steve Smith to New York
  3. 3U.S. Emergency Alert Test Nov. 17 Is Not a Power Outage
  4. 4Brent Crude Slides 4.05% as Rising US Stockpiles Weigh on Oil
  5. 52027 NFL Mock Draft Puts Ohio State’s Jeremiah Smith at No. 1
Advertisement
Don't Miss

Latest News

All stories →
  1. Technology · Apps & SoftwareApple Names 45 Finalists for 2026 App Store AwardsNov 19
  2. Indonesia · NewsMuncar Study Finds Half of Shark Catch ThreatenedNov 19
  3. Technology · AIJPMorgan Tests How AI Works in Currency PaymentsNov 19
  4. Business · Macro & PolicyEPFO Approves Retirement Savings Withdrawals in InstalmentsNov 19
  5. Advertisement
  6. Technology · GamingGrand Theft Auto VI Launches to Strong Reviews WorldwideNov 19
  7. Markets · StocksStocks and Markets to Watch: Target Breakout Meets Broader Mixed SignalsNov 19
  8. Markets · StocksNYSE Challenges Texas Stock Exchange Over Closing PricesNov 19
  9. Markets · StocksAnthropic IPO Fuels US Futures Rally as Nasdaq Contracts Rise 2%Nov 19