JournalArta
Friday, November 20, 2026 · JakartaS&P 7,175.83 ▼2.02%USD/IDR 18,277 ▲0.11%
JournalArta
Global Edition
beyond headlines
Advertisement

COMECE Urges EU Court to Protect Baptismal Registers

COMECE has asked the European Union’s top court to protect baptismal registers from erasure. In a position paper, the Catholic body challenges an advocate general’s opinion and argues that the records document historical events rather than a person’s current religious membership.

By Alistair Sterling
WIB2 min read
COMECE Urges EU Court to Protect Baptismal Registers
COMECE Urges EU Court to Protect Baptismal Registers

COMECE has urged the European Union’s top court to protect baptismal registers from erasure, arguing that the documents record historical events rather than current religious membership. Its position paper challenges an advocate general’s opinion in a case with implications for church-state relations.

The court has not issued its final ruling.

COMECE, a Catholic body in the European Union, prepared the position paper with support from its Legal Affairs Commission. It proposes a different interpretation of the case before the Court of Justice of the European Union.

Church body disputes erasure approach

COMECE says the advocate general’s opinion treats baptismal registers as relevant to defining membership of a religious community. The body argues that the records instead document a historical and sacramental fact.

Advertisement

It says the records serve several purposes in church life. These include establishing sacramental and canonical status, supporting later annotations and issuing reliable certificates throughout a person’s life.

COMECE also says the registers protect third parties’ rights and interests. It rejects the opinion’s proposed alternatives to storing baptismal data as insufficient.

Those alternatives include correspondence with the church about erasure. Another is a church-law provision allowing baptism to be established in certain conditions through a witness declaration or the baptized person’s oath.

COMECE argues that the church’s legitimate grounds for retaining the records should generally outweigh the individual’s interests, rights and freedoms. It also says a baptismal record does not necessarily reveal someone’s present beliefs or religious affiliation.

Advertisement

Annotations and archives at issue

The advocate general’s opinion rejects adding a note in the margin of a baptismal record to reflect the person’s wishes. COMECE defends that practice as a legal solution for situations where it says erasure is not possible.

The body argues that removing a person’s name, surname and date of birth would deprive the record of its essential content and purpose. It also objects to physical alterations such as opaque stickers, citing archival authenticity and integrity.

COMECE says baptismal registers have value for genealogical research and that the integrity of archives matters. It calls for a broader interpretation of public-interest archiving and historical research.

Advertisement

The body warns that the approach in the opinion could create legal uncertainty for church data controllers and increase litigation. It says parishes could face particular difficulties because of administrative limits.

COMECE has followed Case C-12/25, Bisdom Gent, since its inception. Its secretariat prepared a position paper after a hearing in September 2026 and issued a preliminary response to the advocate general’s opinion in October 2026.

Advertisement
What Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizTake the quizWhat Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizStart →
Advertisement
Most Read
  1. 1Stock Market Today: Dow Slides 1.34% and VIX Jumps 15% at MiddayStock Market Today: Dow Slides 1.34% and VIX Jumps 15% at Midday
  2. 2Joachim Klement to Sell Stocks After S&P 500 SignalJoachim Klement to Sell Stocks After S&P 500 Signal
  3. 3Kenneth Walker’s Groin Injury Puts Cardinals Game in DoubtKenneth Walker’s Groin Injury Puts Cardinals Game in Doubt
  4. 4Pat Cummins Faces Captaincy Doubts From Mitchell JohnsonPat Cummins Faces Captaincy Doubts From Mitchell Johnson
  5. 5McDonald’s Workers’ Discrimination Claims Can Go AheadMcDonald’s Workers’ Discrimination Claims Can Go Ahead
Advertisement
Don't Miss

Latest News

All stories →
  1. GTA VI Spurs Streaming Boom With 125.5 Million Hours WatchedTechnology · GamingGTA VI Spurs Streaming Boom With 125.5 Million Hours WatchedNov 20
  2. Jefferies’ Chris Wood Raises India Weight as AI Stocks SlideMarkets · StocksJefferies’ Chris Wood Raises India Weight as AI Stocks SlideNov 20
  3. Asia Stocks Fall to Seven-Month Low as AI Shares SlumpMarkets · StocksAsia Stocks Fall to Seven-Month Low as AI Shares SlumpNov 20
  4. UK Government Borrowing Comes In Below October ForecastBusiness · Macro & PolicyUK Government Borrowing Comes In Below October ForecastNov 20
  5. Advertisement
  6. Gold and Silver Prices Fall as Rate Fears Hit Indian LendersMarkets · Forex & CommoditiesGold and Silver Prices Fall as Rate Fears Hit Indian LendersNov 20
  7. Vikings Build Altitude Room for 49ers Game in Mexico CitySport · FootballVikings Build Altitude Room for 49ers Game in Mexico CityNov 20
  8. Houston Texans Keep Playoff Hopes Alive With 26-3 WinSport · More SportsHouston Texans Keep Playoff Hopes Alive With 26-3 WinNov 20
  9. Daraxonrasib Pill Shows Promise in Pancreatic Cancer TrialLifestyle · Food & HealthDaraxonrasib Pill Shows Promise in Pancreatic Cancer TrialNov 20