JournalArta
Friday, November 20, 2026 · JakartaS&P 7,175.83 ▼2.02%USD/IDR 18,277 ▲0.11%
JournalArta
Global Edition
beyond headlines
Advertisement

SNP Ministers Accused of Ignoring Hospital Death Warnings

A Scottish surgeon says he repeatedly warned first ministers about avoidable surgical deaths at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary. A leaked expert review identified 19 potentially avoidable deaths. First Minister John Swinney says officials followed normal procedures, while police say inquiries are ongoing.

By matthew jonathan
WIB3 min read
SNP Ministers Accused of Ignoring Hospital Death Warnings
SNP Ministers Accused of Ignoring Hospital Death Warnings

A surgeon has accused Scottish National Party (SNP) ministers of ignoring repeated warnings about avoidable deaths at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary in Scotland. Dr. Mohammed Habib released a 2022 expert review that found 19 potentially avoidable deaths among 45 liver and pancreatic surgery patients.

He wants a corporate homicide investigation. The allegations raise questions about how Scotland’s government and health system responded to concerns about surgical safety.

First Minister John Swinney said his administration gave Habib appropriate responses. Police said inquiries into several deaths were ongoing.

Advertisement

Surgeon Sent Four Letters

Habib, a consultant surgeon at the hospital, said he wrote four times to Scotland’s first minister about an alleged cover-up of avoidable deaths.

He wrote to then-first minister Humza Yousaf in June 2023. He wrote to Swinney, Yousaf’s successor, in October 2024, November 2025 and May 2026.

Habib said a civil servant replied each time, directing him to Police Scotland and the Independent National Whistleblowing Officer. That office handles complaints under health service whistleblowing standards.

The whistleblowing office said it could not investigate his criminal negligence complaints. It said they were either too old or predated the introduction of the standards.

Advertisement

Habib said he had heard nothing from police since December. He declined to say whether he believed ministers were part of the alleged cover-up.

At a Glasgow press conference, he estimated that several dozen patients had died unnecessarily and hundreds more were harmed. He also alleged that two people died after being given the wrong operation.

Review Found High Death Rates

The unpublished 2022 review examined 45 patients treated between 2015 and 2021. Of those, 31 died; reviewers thought surgical or treatment complications caused 19 avoidable deaths.

Some patients bled to death in the operating room because of surgical mistakes. Habib said he first became aware of the alleged avoidable deaths in 2016 and formally raised concerns in 2021.

Advertisement

For major liver resections between 2017 and 2020, the review found a 12% death rate after 30 days and 18% after 90 days. Liver resection is surgery to remove part of the liver.

For pancreatic surgery, the death rate was 15% at 30 days and 17% at 90 days. A previous study suggested respective rates of 3.7% and 9.4%.

Reviewers said patients were regularly rushed into surgery without adequate planning or consideration of non-surgical alternatives. They also found high blood losses and criticized decisions to operate in some cases when disease was thought to be inoperable.

A second report in 2026 raised similar concerns. It strongly recommended that the hospital stop carrying out complex or major liver and pancreatic surgery.

Advertisement

Police Continue Death Inquiries

Swinney said he had only recently seen Habib’s letters because officials handled them at the time. He said normal procedures were followed and warned NHS Grampian that the government would intervene unless it improved.

Detective Superintendent Carron McKellar said: “We received a report in 2024 following several deaths. Enquiries are being carried out, and a situational report will be submitted to the Procurator Fiscal.”

NHS Grampian Chief Executive Laura Skaife-Knight said a thorough investigation had taken place and some work remained ongoing. She said the health board would carefully consider any new evidence or information.

Advertisement
What Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizTake the quizWhat Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizStart →
Advertisement
Most Read
  1. 1Stock Market Today: Dow Slides 1.34% and VIX Jumps 15% at MiddayStock Market Today: Dow Slides 1.34% and VIX Jumps 15% at Midday
  2. 2Joachim Klement to Sell Stocks After S&P 500 SignalJoachim Klement to Sell Stocks After S&P 500 Signal
  3. 3Kenneth Walker’s Groin Injury Puts Cardinals Game in DoubtKenneth Walker’s Groin Injury Puts Cardinals Game in Doubt
  4. 4Pat Cummins Faces Captaincy Doubts From Mitchell JohnsonPat Cummins Faces Captaincy Doubts From Mitchell Johnson
  5. 5McDonald’s Workers’ Discrimination Claims Can Go AheadMcDonald’s Workers’ Discrimination Claims Can Go Ahead
Advertisement
Don't Miss

Latest News

All stories →
  1. Asian Stocks Head for Worst Week Since 2020 as AI Shares SlideMarkets · StocksAsian Stocks Head for Worst Week Since 2020 as AI Shares SlideNov 20
  2. FTSE 100 Futures Slip as US Rate Expectations RiseMarkets · StocksFTSE 100 Futures Slip as US Rate Expectations RiseNov 20
  3. Grey’s Anatomy Fall Finale Leaves Wes Unable to Feel His LegsLifestyle · EntertainmentGrey’s Anatomy Fall Finale Leaves Wes Unable to Feel His LegsNov 20
  4. Persib Bandung Beats Shan United 6-0 in ASEAN Club CupIndonesia · NewsPersib Bandung Beats Shan United 6-0 in ASEAN Club CupNov 20
  5. Advertisement
  6. TSMC Halts Advanced China Chip Orders Under US RulesIndonesia · NewsTSMC Halts Advanced China Chip Orders Under US RulesNov 20
  7. Anthropic IPO Lifts Tech Stock Futures Before Nasdaq DebutMarkets · StocksAnthropic IPO Lifts Tech Stock Futures Before Nasdaq DebutNov 20
  8. IHSG Today: Jakarta Stocks Slip 0.92% as Global AI Selloff Hits AsiaMarkets · StocksIHSG Today: Jakarta Stocks Slip 0.92% as Global AI Selloff Hits AsiaNov 20
  9. GTA VI Spurs Streaming Boom With 125.5 Million Hours WatchedTechnology · GamingGTA VI Spurs Streaming Boom With 125.5 Million Hours WatchedNov 20