AFL Clubs Back Ending Father-Son Rule in Wider Overhaul
Eleven of 19 AFL clubs want the father-son rule scrapped as part of a broader overhaul of player movement. Clubs also unanimously backed an industry forum ahead of potential changes in 2030, with free agency, draft picks and talent development among the issues under review.

Eleven of 19 AFL clubs want the father-son rule scrapped as part of a broader overhaul of player movement. Most clubs would keep the fan-favorite rule, however, if other draft advantages linked to academies were not also addressed.
All 19 clubs, including incoming club Tasmania, took part in a survey covering the draft, free agency and talent development. Representatives spoke anonymously so they could discuss the issues freely.
The clubs unanimously supported an industry-wide forum, with potential changes in 2030. That would give clubs time to prepare after the next two drafts, which are affected by Tasmania building its playing list.
Clubs seek a draft reset
Clubs said the draft had accumulated annual changes and no longer operated as a fair means of distributing talent. Father-son and academy ties can restrict lower-ranked teams' access to highly rated players.
One senior football figure said the draft was no longer delivering competitive balance. The figure also criticized compensation picks when lower-ranked clubs lose free agents to stronger teams.
Views differed on northern academies. Seven clubs supported them, six wanted them scrapped and six said the NSW academy remained necessary but Queensland no longer needed one.
Most clubs said northern academies had helped develop talent, but objected to how their players were distributed. Clubs also wanted more investment in pathways in Victoria, South Australia and Western Australia.
The majority were skeptical of the new Indigenous rookie list. They questioned whether it would address neglected development pathways beyond a possible short-term increase in Indigenous players.
Free agency and trades face scrutiny
All 19 clubs wanted free agency reviewed. They said it had not achieved its intended effect of helping lower-ranked clubs attract quality players with money to spend.
Recently retired former Sydney and Brisbane Lions list manager Kinnear Beatson agreed. “The best free agents have not gone to the low clubs. They have to look at a change there,” he said.
Fifteen clubs wanted changes to prevent side deals like those attached to the moves of Zak Butters from Port Adelaide to the Western Bulldogs and Ben King from Gold Coast to Hawthorn.
All clubs also backed allowing draft picks to be bought using salary cap space. The proposal would let clubs acquire picks without a player being included in the deal.
They unanimously wanted the right to trade players above a certain pay threshold without their consent. Clubs doubted the proposal would be approved because of opposition from the AFL Players’ Association.
The survey took place before the national draft. Under revised rules, the Brisbane Lions lacked the points to match Sydney’s bid for academy player Caylen Murray at pick No. 9.
Take the quizWhat Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizStart →
Markets · FintechHow to Calculate Compound Interest: Formula, Examples and the Rule of 72
Lifestyle · Food & HealthNormal Blood Pressure Chart by Age: Healthy Ranges Explained
Lifestyle · Food & HealthWhat Is Raynaud’s Syndrome? Why Fingers Turn White in the Cold
Lifestyle · Food & Health4 Ways Walking After Meals Helps Your Body, Doctors Say




















