Gwent Police Misconduct Hearing Told Officers Lied About Searches
Two Gwent Police officers face gross misconduct allegations over claims they falsely logged searches for two women later found in a car crash in St Mellons, Cardiff. The officers deny the allegations. A hearing in Newport is considering whether they should be dismissed.

Gwent Police officers Richard Hardwick and Lauren Livingstone face gross misconduct allegations at a hearing in Newport over searches for two women before a fatal crash in St Mellons, Cardiff, in 2023. The case examines whether the officers falsely recorded searches as they looked for missing women whose car was found two days later.
Both officers attended the hearing and denied all allegations. If gross misconduct is proven against either, they would be dismissed without notice.
The hearing was told that Hardwick and Livingstone recorded searches at the homes of Eve Smith and Sophie Russon. Smith died in the crash, which killed three of the five people in the car.
Stephen Morley, a barrister representing Gwent Police’s professional standards department, said the officers were assigned to visit the two homes during a shift running from 16:00 to 03:00. He described the task as “common sense” in a missing person inquiry.
The panel heard that Livingstone was assigned to Smith’s home and Hardwick to Russon’s, but the officers went to both addresses together. Livingstone’s log said, “Nothing missing out of the usual,” and recorded that Smith’s mother believed she had left in the same clothes.
Morley called the entry “dishonest and misleading.” Hardwick’s log said “Premise search conducted,” which Morley said was dishonest.
Statements from both families said no searches had taken place. Russon’s father said he would not have allowed officers to search his daughter’s bedroom.
Morley told the panel there was “no reason to doubt” the families’ evidence. He said the officers had also told Sgt Cheverton, who was overseeing the investigation, that the searches had happened.
The three women—Smith, Russon and Darcy Ross—had gone out together in Newport on March 2, 2023, the hearing was told. They later met three men and traveled to a caravan in Trecco Bay, Porthcawl, for a party.
The group left in the early hours, Morley said. The car crashed in woodland shortly after dropping off one passenger in Cardiff.
By the evening of March 3, the women’s families had been unable to contact them for hours and reported them missing to Gwent Police. Ross’s mother and Russon’s father went to Newport central police station; Smith was reported missing by her sister a couple of hours later.
Smith’s mother had gone to the caravan and found her daughter’s handbag, but no sign of the group. Morley said the circumstances had become “something was very wrong” for her.
The hearing was told that the officers’ actions “may not have made any difference” to the crash’s outcome. Morley said that was “neither here nor there” and called the alleged conduct “a serious failing.”
In a statement to the Independent Office for Police Conduct, Hardwick denied the allegations and said he searched Russon’s bedroom. Livingstone told the watchdog she had not “knowingly been untruthful in her accounts,” but could not remember whether searches took place.
The hearing is expected to continue until the end of the week.
Take the quizWhat Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizStart →
Lifestyle7 Signs Your Social Battery Is Running Low (and Why You Keep Cancelling Plans)
Lifestyle · Food & HealthThanksgiving Food Safety: How Long Leftovers Last and the Safe Turkey Temperature
Lifestyle7 Quiet Habits of Emotionally Intelligent People, According to Psychologists
LifestylePeople Who Don’t Like Celebrating Their Birthday Often Share These 7 Traits

















