NSW Premier Chris Minns Shelves Property Price Reforms
New South Wales Premier Chris Minns shelved planned underquoting reforms hours before they were due to take effect. In neighboring Victoria, sellers must disclose auction reserve prices in advance, and early property data shows mixed results.

NSW Premier Chris Minns shelved property underquoting reforms hours before they were due to take effect. He said real estate agents in his electorate warned that the rules would make selling harder. The decision leaves buyers without planned safeguards against misleading price guides.
Underquoting occurs when a property’s advertised price is substantially lower than the seller’s actual expectations. The practice can attract bidders who cannot afford the final price, leaving them with inspection and other preparation costs.
Sydney buyer Linda Assaf experienced it twice while searching for a home in the city’s inner west. One property sold for $100,000 above its guide price; another went for $200,000 more than she had been told.
“We thought that we had a chance,” Assaf said of the second auction, after paying for checks and due diligence.
Victoria requires earlier price disclosure
In Victoria, sellers must publish their auction reserve price at least one week before the sale. The reserve is the lowest price a seller is genuinely willing to accept. Vendors and agents must also inform buyers about comparable nearby sales and publish their property sale prices.
The rules do not require sellers to accept a bid that matches the guide or reserve. Agents also do not have to publish a reserve when a property is sold without an auction and without a fixed sale date.
The Real Estate Institute of Victoria has called for a review and possible repeal. It has said the rules could increase failed auctions, inflate reserve prices and make sales riskier.
Melbourne’s auction clearance rate has fallen since the reforms took effect, though Sydney’s has fallen further. Official interest rates have risen to their highest level in 18 years, following five rate increases this year.
Cotality, a property data firm, found that new listings have increasingly favored private sales. Melbourne is hosting far fewer auctions than a year ago, although auction numbers have risen overall in recent months.
Gerard Burg, Cotality’s head of research, said it was unclear whether the reforms or interest rate changes were responsible for weaker auction volumes.
Sales data shows a price gap
Property data app Homer analyzed 2,164 sales in the past month. Most sellers initially advertised prices matching their reserves, but one in six published higher reserves before auction, as required by the Victorian rules.
| Reserve compared with price guide | Sale rate |
|---|---|
| Matched the guide | 59% |
| Higher than the guide | 50.4% |
Homer Chief Executive Henry Pedersen said the reforms had not ended underquoting but had “shifted and exposed it.” Buyers could see the gap a week before auction rather than on the day, he said.
NSW package faced agent objections
The shelved NSW package proposed higher fines for underquoting and a requirement to include a price guide in every advertisement. Minns objected to a proposed restriction on cutting an advertised price below an agent’s private estimate or a previous rejected offer.
He argued that the restriction could prevent sellers who had overvalued a property from adjusting to the market. Sydney buyers’ agent Kimberley Ackerman said that element was poorly designed, but the rest of the package could have been saved.
Take the quizWhat Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizStart →
Markets · FintechHow to Calculate Compound Interest: Formula, Examples and the Rule of 72
Lifestyle · Food & HealthNormal Blood Pressure Chart by Age: Healthy Ranges Explained
Lifestyle · Food & HealthWhat Is Raynaud’s Syndrome? Why Fingers Turn White in the Cold
Lifestyle · Food & Health4 Ways Walking After Meals Helps Your Body, Doctors Say




















