JournalArta
Monday, November 23, 2026 · JakartaS&P 6,910.39 ▼3.70%USD/IDR 18,158 ▼0.42%
JournalArta
Global Edition
beyond headlines
Advertisement

Zimmer Biomet Faces Lawsuits Over Smart Knee Implants

Two California patients allege they received connected knee implants without informed consent. The cases come as Medicare pays for remote monitoring and researchers question whether smart devices improve patient outcomes.

By matthew jonathan
WIB3 min read
Zimmer Biomet Faces Lawsuits Over Smart Knee Implants
Zimmer Biomet Faces Lawsuits Over Smart Knee Implants

Two California patients are suing Zimmer Biomet and others after receiving smart knee implants they say were placed without informed consent. The cases raise questions about patient choice as connected health devices drive monitoring costs and researchers seek evidence that they improve outcomes.

Medicare and private insurers pay clinicians to review data from connected devices. Some researchers say the health benefits are unproven.

Steve Russak, 70, of Santa Rosa Valley, said he learned about his implant after surgery when Zimmer Biomet contacted him about an app. A company representative later offered to help him set up accessories.

Advertisement

His Persona IQ knee contains a lithium-ion battery, sensors and a transmitter. If Russak authorizes it, the device can send information about his gait and range of motion to his clinicians and Zimmer Biomet.

Russak is suing his doctor, Zimmer Biomet and Canary Medical, which helped develop the implant. His lawsuit alleges he was not offered a chance to decline the knee or opt out of data collection.

He said privacy was among his reasons for not activating the device. He also said compatibility issues recently prevented him from getting an MRI.

Patients allege missing consent

Jodi Murphy filed a separate lawsuit in Contra Costa County against Zimmer Biomet, Canary Medical and her doctor. She alleges she received a Persona IQ implant and was registered for Zimmer’s app without specific informed consent.

Advertisement

Murphy’s doctor and her practice denied the allegations. Zimmer’s attorneys said the company did not practice medicine or have a legal duty to obtain consent for treatment provided by her physician.

In Russak’s case, Zimmer and Canary denied the allegations in initial court responses. The doctor has not yet responded to the complaint in court.

Russak said he dropped fraud and breach of fiduciary duty allegations against his doctor but is pursuing other claims, including lack of informed consent. A hearing in his case is scheduled for December; Murphy’s case has a hearing scheduled for February.

Zimmer spokesperson Troy Kirkpatrick said transmission of recovery data requires authorization when a patient sets up an account. He said the system is designed to support postoperative care.

Advertisement

Medicare pays for remote monitoring

Nearly 1 million Medicare beneficiaries received remote patient monitoring in 2024, according to the Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of Inspector General. Medicare paid providers $536 million for the service, more than double its payment three years earlier.

The figures cover monitoring across connected devices, not just knee implants. Medicare is the federal health program for older Americans and some people with disabilities.

The inspector general warned of fraud risks and found about 43% of patients in 2024 did not receive the full set of defined services. Those services include teaching patients about their devices and monitoring data for health changes.

Advertisement

Medicare has proposed reducing some reimbursements. Russak’s Medicare account shows payment for his surgery and implant, but no claims for monitoring the knee, which he has not activated.

Zimmer’s website says Persona IQ is not intended to support clinical decision-making and has not been shown to provide a clinical benefit. The company also describes potential payments for surgeons who monitor patients remotely.

Kevin Bozic, chair of surgery and perioperative care at the University of Texas, reviewed research supplied by Zimmer. “None of them compare Persona IQ to a more conventional [knee] implant,” he wrote.

Advertisement
What Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizTake the quizWhat Kind of Holiday Spender Are You? Take the Black Friday QuizStart →
Advertisement
Most Read
  1. 1GTA 6 Draws Review Bombing on MetacriticGTA 6 Draws Review Bombing on Metacritic
  2. 2Dow Jones Futures Await Reopening After Tech Stocks SlideDow Jones Futures Await Reopening After Tech Stocks Slide
  3. 3Micron Says Memory Has Changed as Shares Fall 13.89%Micron Says Memory Has Changed as Shares Fall 13.89%
  4. 4Stocks to Watch This Week: Nvidia, Workday, Deere and Thanksgiving PCE DataStocks to Watch This Week: Nvidia, Workday, Deere and Thanksgiving PCE Data
  5. 5Brielle Biermann Marries Billy Seidl in Naples, FloridaBrielle Biermann Marries Billy Seidl in Naples, Florida
Advertisement
Don't Miss

Latest News

All stories →
  1. Telstra Share Price Latest: Little Changed on Friday, Up 4.9% in a MonthMarkets · StocksTelstra Share Price Latest: Little Changed on Friday, Up 4.9% in a MonthNov 23
  2. BepiColombo Enters Mercury Orbit After Eight-Year JourneyTechnologyBepiColombo Enters Mercury Orbit After Eight-Year JourneyNov 23
  3. NOAA Scientists Find Appliances During Shipwreck HuntTechnologyNOAA Scientists Find Appliances During Shipwreck HuntNov 23
  4. Qantas Airways Share Price Little Changed on Friday, Up 14.8% in a MonthMarkets · StocksQantas Airways Share Price Little Changed on Friday, Up 14.8% in a MonthNov 23
  5. Advertisement
  6. Scentre Share Price Little Changed on Friday, Up 1.1% in a MonthMarkets · StocksScentre Share Price Little Changed on Friday, Up 1.1% in a MonthNov 23
  7. Cardinals vs. Chiefs: Josh Johnson Gets Start After Beck InjurySport · More SportsCardinals vs. Chiefs: Josh Johnson Gets Start After Beck InjuryNov 23
  8. Tim Burchett Calls Parents Wrong to Let Kids Play GTA VITechnology · GamingTim Burchett Calls Parents Wrong to Let Kids Play GTA VINov 23
  9. Delta System Failure Delays Flights Nationwide During Thanksgiving RushWorld · United StatesDelta System Failure Delays Flights Nationwide During Thanksgiving RushNov 23